This week’s Grade the Trade opens with a monster; three startup first-rounders collide in a blockbuster that would have any league buzzing. Next, we break down a 1QB league upgrade that puts Josh Allen in the driver’s seat for a championship run. And finally, a long-term vision from a rebuilder gives us a peek behind the curtain of dynasty patience.
Grade Ratings:
A – Great Trade for Both Parties
B – Leans One Side, But Fair
C – Questionable, But Defensible
D – Lopsided Deal
F – Borderline Collusion Deal
Trade #1 | B | Grade the Trade
Ja’Marr Chase, Breece Hall, Michael Penix, James Conner, and Jaydon Blue for Jahmyr Gibbs, Jalen Hurts, Terry McLaurin, D’Andre Swift, and 2026 1st
“Which side”, asks Medium_Armadillo6503.
This is a heavy-hitting preseason trade with seismic shifts across the league landscape. Flags are being planted in August as two contenders exchange 1st round startup talents like Ja’Marr Chase, Jalen Hurts, and Jahmyr Gibbs to cement their team’s identity. It’s a deal that sets the tone, not just for the season, but for this league’s balance of power.
Team 3 and Team 4, both firmly in the hunt, are jockeying for projected playoff seeding, making bold moves that reflect their vision for the 2025 season. Two win-now builds with two different philosophies yield one massive trade.
TEAM 3 | Terry McLaurin, Jalen Hurts, DeAndre Swift, Jahmyr Gibbs, & 26 1st
PROs.
- Jalen Hurts is locked in as a top-tier fantasy QB for the foreseeable future.
- Jahmyr Gibbs is quickly establishing himself as one of the most electric playmakers in the NFL.
- Terry McLaurin is coming off his best season, with unsurprisingly, the best QB of his career.
- A 2026 1st will appreciate all season long.
CONs
- D’Andre Swift offers immediate value, but his 2025 outlook is murkier than we want to admit.
- Terry McLaurin has gone from a hold-in to an outright trade request. The vibes are not great.
- The 2026 1st belongs to the trade partner, so it’s expected late.
TEAM 4 | Michael Penix, James Conner, Breece Hall, Jayden Blue, and Ja’Marr Chase
PROs
- Ja’Marr Chase. Period.
- Breece Hall holds a top 10 consensus RB ranking among the community.
- Michael Penix earned a multi-year window with some high-end weapons at his disposal.
- Jaydon Blue steps into an unsettled backfield and brings explosion for days.
- James Conner has a huge year ahead of him…
CONs
- … But it’s likely Conner’s last season if he even holds up.
- Losing a QB1 in SuperFlex and a PPR star RB just before his prime is a heavy hit to the roster.
- Breece Hall’s future value has a lot of undetermined variables.
- Penix’s ceiling is low without a solid rushing floor.
VERDICT: Team B gets the boost in this one with a double dose of premium talent.
With all this talent flying around, let’s break it down into positional groups to uncover where real advantages lie.
At quarterback, Jalen Hurts is a clear upgrade over Michael Penix, both short and long term. Locked-in elite production and concrete value insulation, Hurts gives Team B a major edge.
At wide receiver, Ja’Marr Chase offers a massive ceiling that Terry McLaurin can’t match, even when you toss in a 2026 1st to help bridge the gap.
The running back rooms are where things get interesting.
Team A boasts Breece Hall, James Conner, and Jaydon Blue, a group that offers a variety of pathways but also carries volatility. Hall has top-10 upside, but Conner’s age and Blue’s uncertainty could lead to fast depreciation.
Team B counters with Jahmyr Gibbs and D’Andre Swift. Swift’s outlook is murky, but Gibbs is one of the league’s most exciting NFL and fantasy players.
So where does that leave us?
Team B may be “Chase”ing points at wide receiver, but upgrades at QB1 and RB1 anchor this deal in their favor. That said, if Hall hits his ceiling, Penix keeps climbing, and Chase keeps torching secondaries, Team A can close the value gap and convert this risk into a title.
Dynasty Value | Trade Calculator
Contender Value | Trade Calculator
Trade #2 | B+ | Grade the Trade
Josh Allen and 2027 2nd for C.J. Stroud and Marvin Harrison
Centuari wanted some help with this equation: “Stroud +MHJ for Josh?”
We play this game for many reasons, but mostly to have fun, win, and make bold moves. That’s exactly what Centauri is doing here: pushing chips in for Josh Allen by leveraging a position they feel comfortable overpaying from.
In a 1QB league with 9 starters and 3 flex spots, depth matters, but the jump from C.J. Stroud to Josh Allen is massive.
Marvin Harrison Jr. may be valued slightly ahead of Allen in 1QB formats, but that extra 2026 2nd gives Team A flexibility to fill MHJ’s immediate absence. If Allen vaults Centauri into contender status, the price makes sense—despite the gamble.
TEAM A | Josh Allen & 2027 2nd
PROs
- Josh Allen is a gamechanger in any format.
- 2027 2nd is a great chip to hold
CONs
- Taking a value hit in the short term, likely bigger in the long term.
TEAM B | C.J. Stroud & Marvin Harrison
PROs
- C. J. Stroud appears to have a long NFL career ahead of him.
- Marvin Harrison Jr. is a great acquisition in a tier-down opportunity.
CONs
- Could get a case of the Josh Stallion blues.
Verdict: Team B gets the edge over time, but that’s worth Team A going for the 2025 ring.
C.J. Stroud may sit at QB11 in rankings, but the weekly point gap between him and Josh Allen is nearly 10 PPG, that’s an extra flex starter. That’s the swing Centauri is betting on.
Marvin Harrison Jr. has all the tools to become a Hall of Famer, and I expect the breakout to begin soon. But this manager is chasing points today, and believes they can win without MHJ in the lineup.
Josh Allen won’t keep producing like a Greek demi-god forever (I know, I’m grieving, too), but he’s still at the peak of his powers and in full Super Bowl-or-bust mode.
Trade #3 | B | Grade the Trade
Jaylen Waddle, Jayden Higgins, & 2026 2nd for Zay Flowers and Brandon Aiyuk
The manager reached out to me directly to walk through the thought process behind this move. I always appreciate when readers bring their strategy into the overall context of the deal.
Team B is in the midst of a full-scale rebuild, coming off an offseason focused on stacking value for the future. Not every move is about today’s market; sometimes you’re playing for tomorrow’s value spike.
Jaylen Waddle’s upside has been capped by injuries, both his own and Tagovailoa’s, while Jayden Higgins gained strong draft capital and is a popular pick post-NFL Draft. Zay Flowers is explosive, but tied to a run-heavy offense, and Brandon Aiyuk remains a wild card, returning to a messy depth chart that offers both opportunity and volatility.
These players’ trajectories are open to interpretation. At first, I leaned much more favorably toward the Waddle side until the manager reached out and laid out their full vision. Aiyuk and Flowers aren’t being treated as foundational pieces; they’re fluid, much like future picks. This manager is already targeting the first big game from either player as a prime sell-high opportunity, and they believe that spike will come quicker than it would with Waddle or Higgins.
That’s a sharp way to approach a rebuild, not just acquiring value today, but positioning for an even bigger gain tomorrow through anticipatory moves.
Depending on your rebuild philosophy, you could make the case for either side. I still lean toward Waddle and Higgins, but the argument was strong enough to bump my grade up.
TEAM A | Waddle, Jayden Higgins, & late 2026 2nd
PROs
- Jaylen Waddle has displayed WR1 ceiling, and Tyreek Hill may be singing his swan song.
- Jayden Higgins enters as the 34th overall player selected, and a team looking for Nico Collins’ sidekick.
CONs
- Waddle is untrustworthy, both he and his QB/HC situation.
- Higgins’ ceiling is limited by Collins’ presence and HOU offensive philosophy.
TEAM B | Zay Flowers & Brandon Aiyuk
PROs
- Zay Flowers has the offense and talent to be a WR1 any given week.
- Brandon Aiyuk has shown the ceiling to be WR14.
CONs
- Flower’s season is a rollercoaster that leaves an egg or two in the score column.
- Aiyuk is a high-risk, high-reward player.
VERDICT: You don’t need to win deals today to execute a plan for tomorrow.
This is the current dynasty landscape following a flurry of summer trades, capped off by Team 2’s latest move to acquire Zay Flowers and Brandon Aiyuk. As it stands, Team 2 now ranks second overall in dynasty value, and that’s without factoring in their 2028 1sts or giving much weight to their 2026 and 2027 2nds.
The strategy is clear: acquire players poised for value spikes. Zay Flowers will have his share of explosive weeks that inflate his market, while Aiyuk remains a high-upside asset who could take over the WR1 role in San Francisco—or headline a trade when his value surges. These are both players that will be very attractive to contenders in the right window.
Dynasty Trade Value
Contender Trade Value
Submit Your Own Trade!
Got a trade of your own? Hit me up on Reddit or drop it, with as much context as possible, in the DynastyNerds subreddit, and you might see it featured next. If you want more Grade the Trade, check out last week’s edition:
