One of the biggest challenges in dynasty fantasy football is determining whether a breakout season is sustainable. Managers constantly debate whether a player’s elite finish represents long-term value or simply a one-year spike. The Dynasty Nerds returned with one of their most popular annual data-driven discussions: how often elite fantasy football players repeat top-tier performances from one season to the next. Rich, Matt, and Garret focused on identifying trends, repeat rates, and historical outcomes for players who finished inside the top 6 or 12 at their position.
Start Building Your Dynasty
Repeating Success at Running Back
Since 2023, the fantasy football RB1 landscape has experienced a major youth movement. In 2023 alone, 8 of the top 12 running backs finished as RB1s for the first time, creating a massive wave of new breakout players. Most of those backs were either rookies or second-year players, including Breece Hall, Travis Etienne, Rachaad White, Kyren Williams, Bijan Robinson, Jahmyr Gibbs, and James Cook, with Raheem Mostert being the lone veteran exception.
What stands out is the staying power of the 2022 and 2023 draft classes. After that huge influx in 2023, only two new RB1 names appeared in 2024—De’Von Achane and Chase Brown—and only two more joined in 2025—Ashton Jeanty and Javonte Williams. The broader trend shows that younger running backs are entering fantasy relevance earlier and maintaining RB1 production longer. Looking at data dating back to 2009, more players are now accumulating multiple RB1 seasons, with several running backs already reaching two or three top-tier fantasy finishes early in their careers.
Over the last 17 years of fantasy football data, Alvin Kamara remains the top benchmark for sustained elite RB production with seven RB1 seasons and eight total RB1/RB2 finishes — the only player to reach seven elite seasons in that span. Two other running backs are close behind and have a chance to join Kamara at the top. Christian McCaffrey also has six RB1 seasons, all at a first-round fantasy value level. Derrick Henry has six RB1 seasons plus two additional RB2 seasons.
With a weaker incoming rookie running back draft class outside of Jeremiyah Love, it’s less likely that new backs will immediately challenge these long-term production leaders. However, Jonathan Taylor, Saquon Barkley, and Josh Jacobs all already have four RB1 seasons and possess the capability to do it again this year. Younger running backs such as James Cook, Kyren Williams, Bijan Robinson, and Jahmyr Gibbs already have three RB1 seasons under their belts.
Quick Breakdown:
- 1-Year Wonders (28 players): 43.75% of all RB1 seasons come from players who only produce for one single year.
- 2+ Seasons (36 players): 56.25% manage a second RB1 year.
- 3+ Seasons (26 players): 40.63%.
- 4+ Seasons (12 players): 18.75% — the true “studs”.
- 5+ Seasons (5 players): 7.81% — the elite of the elite (think the rare CMC, Kamara, or Derrick Henry types).
The data shows that running backs are trending towards more long-term value than in previous years. The takeaway from these numbers is to show that Bijan Robinson and Jahmyr Gibbs have established themselves as top 6 dynasty picks, even in Superflex formats. At only 24-years old, they represent a rare tier of security and elite production.
Want in-depth analysis all week long?
Catch the latest insights on the Dynasty Nerds Podcast—streaming on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.
Repeating Success at Quarterback
Moving toward the quarterback position, there is not a shift occurring like we are currently seeing with the running backs. In evaluating the quarterbacks, we evaluate on a top 6 finish instead of top 12, as there is not a massive difference in a QB11 finish to a QB17 finish. A top six finish is showing the true difference makers. In 2025, the top 6 quarterbacks were Josh Allen, Drake Maye, Matthew Stafford, Trevor Lawrence, Dak Prescott, and Caleb Wiliams.
Josh Allen has played eight seasons. Seven of those have been top six, and six of those eight have been top three. Those percentages equate to 85% of his career he has had a top six finish, and 71% of his career he has finished as a top three fantasy quarterback. The next closest names are Aaron Rodgers (10) and Patrick Mahomes (4), with 50% of their NFL seasons finishing as a top-six quarterback. The only other quarterbacks with three top-six season finishes are Dak Prescott, Deshaun Watson, Lamar Jackson, and Matthew Stafford. Jalen Hurts, Jared Goff, Kirk Cousins, and Joe Burrow currently have two seasons. Finally, Justin Herbert, Kyler Murray, Trevor Lawrence, Baker Mayfield, Jordan Love, Drake Maye, Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, and Brock Purdy all only have one season where they finished inside the top six in scoring.
To sum this up, if you are a top-six quarterback, more than likely you are a top 12 fantasy scorer, as quarterbacks score the most points. If you can get two of these guys, it makes a massive difference in helping you win a fantasy championship.
Ready to take control of your dynasty? Use the Dynasty Nerds App to see where your roster truly ranks.
Repeating Success at Wide Receiver
At wide receiver, we had 7 of the top 12 guys repeat as a WR1. Those names were Puka Nacua, Jaxson Smith-Njigba, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Ja’Marr Chase, Nico Collins, Davante Adams, and A.J. Brown. Joining the WR1 list for the first time were George Pickens, Chris Olave, Zay Flowers, and Michael Wilson.
Going back to 2004, Larry Fitzgerald played in 17 seasons and finished in the top 12 among wide receivers in 9 of those seasons. Davante Adams is approaching elite territory if he can finish inside the top 12, joining Fitzgerald as the only other wide receiver to have 9 top 12 seasons while doing so in only 12 seasons. What is even more impressive is that out of those 8 seasons, 4 of those seasons Adams has finished in the top 3 amongst wide receivers.
Ja’Marr Chase has been inside the top 12 in all 5 of his NFL seasons. Amon-Ra St. Brown has finished as a top 12 wide receiver in 80% of his NFL career seasons. Some of the notable wide receivers with only one top 12 finish include: Chris Godwin, DK Metcalf, Calvin Ridley, Deebo Samuel, Jaylen Waddle, Devonta Smith, Terry McLaurin, Garrett Wilson, Drake London, Jameson Williams, Chris Olave, and George Pickens.
Production Breakdown
| WR1 Longevity | # of Players | % of Total WR1s |
|---|---|---|
| 1-Year Wonder | 44 | 51.16% |
| 2+ Seasons | 42 | 48.84% |
| 3+ Seasons | 27 | 31.40% |
| 4+ Seasons | 20 | 23.26% |
| 5+ Seasons | 14 | 16.28% |
| 6+ Seasons | 7 | 8.14% |
| 7+ Seasons | 4 | 4.65% |
The key numbers to look at here are the “one and done” reality: 51.16% of players who achieve a WR1 season never do it again. There is a steep drop-off after year 2. Only about 1 in 4 WR1s (23.26%) manage to sustain that level of production for 4 or more seasons with names such as Justin Jefferson (4), Stefon Diggs (5), Mike Evans (5), and Tyreek Hill (5). Achieving 7 or more WR1 seasons is extremely rare, accomplished by just 4.65% of the players in this dataset.
Prefer visuals?
Watch our full analysis and player breakdowns on the Dynasty Nerds YouTube Channel — Subscribe Here
Repeating Success at Tight End
When evaluating the tight end position, we will track top-six fantasy finishes because the position is so elite-heavy. In 2025, Jake Ferguson, Tyler Warren, and Harold Fanin Jr. all finished inside the top six for the first time, joining Travis Kelce, Trey McBride, and Kyle Pitts. As rookies, Warren and Fanin making the list is a positive indicator for long-term fantasy success. An exception to that would be Trey McBride, as he did not post his first top-six finish until his third year in the league. Kelce has finished as a top-six tight end in 11 of his 13 seasons, with 9 of those seasons being a top-three finish.
Some tight ends with multiple top-six finishes include: George Kittle (6) and Mark Andrews (5). However, using the last 15+ years of fantasy football data, more than half of the top-six seasons came from “one-year wonder” tight ends. Out of 56 total top-six finishes, 30 only produced a single top-six season (53.57%).
However, sustained elite production is much rarer. The data highlights how difficult long-term elite consistency is at the tight end position, making players with repeated top-six finishes exceptionally valuable.
- 46.4% recorded multiple top-six seasons
- 33.9% reached at least three
- 21.4% achieved four or more
- 14.3% produced five+ seasons
- 7.1% posted eight or more seasons
Links to all this data that Garret has compiled can be found below:
Running Backs
Quarterbacks
Wide Receivers
Tight Ends
Take Control of Your Dynasty Today
Take Control of Your Dynasty TodayWant to see where your lineup stacks up? Start building like the pros with our most powerful tools and resources:
It’s time to take control of your dynasty and see where your lineups truly rank.
